Skip to Content

Blind Grass-Fed Butter Taste Test

Can I guess which brand of grass-fed butter I’m eating in this blind butter taste test?

Grass-Fed Butter Blind Taste Test

Back when I did my initial grass-fed butter review, I decided that it would be fun to test my skills and see if I could tell the different brands apart. While blindfolded! So I braved my fear of sitting in front of a camera with Reuben around (does anyone else get really embarrassed if their spouse is around while they’re recording?!), and made this video for y’all!

I got all the butters set up and Reuben spoon-fed me each one while writing down my answers in a notebook.

Blind Butter Taste Test

You can see how I did by watching the video above! I was kind of surprised with my results…


Blind Butter Taste Test

That’s right: I got 5 out of 5, 100% correct! That just goes to show that each of those grass-fed butters have a distinct flavor. The Organic Valley is quite cultured, almost cheesy. The Graziers has a buttercream frosting flavor. The Kerrygold is just straight-up good butter. The Anchor has a distinct, almost grassy flavor, etc. etc.

I highly encourage you to get your hands on as many grass-fed butters as possible and give them a taste test. Personally, I like to try it on bread or a cracker as well as all by itself. This gives me a good idea of how much I like it.

If you’re interested in reading more about these brands of grass-fed butter, make sure to check out my initial Grass-fed Butter Review and my Updated Grass-fed Butter Review  In those posts I go into detail about color, ingredients, price, etc. Make sure to check out the comment section on those posts as well since there have been some good conversations!


Sunday 3rd of June 2018

Nicely done! Now I am curious to try it for myself :)

Erica Kastner

Monday 4th of June 2018

Thank you! ? Yes, it's really fun! You should try it. ✨


Friday 1st of June 2018

Glad to have found your website, fellow butter lover! Love your taste test, good job!!

Erica Kastner

Friday 1st of June 2018

Thank you! And welcome! ?✨


Friday 1st of June 2018

Gosh, I had no idea that each butter flavor is so distinct. Well done Erica!

Erica Kastner

Friday 1st of June 2018

Yes, they can be SO different! Thank you, Devon. ?


Thursday 31st of May 2018

That's so cool. :) Also I haven't been to your blog in 2 yrs - you've changed it sm! I still love it though. ;) I never knew you could taste the difference. Now I want to go get some grass-fed stuff to try. :P

Erica Kastner

Friday 1st of June 2018

Glad to have you back, Maxwell! Do you mean that the layout of the website has changed, or the actual content? ? Yes, definitely give grass-fed butter a try! ?

Subscribe for access to my FREE E-Book!

Join my mailing list and get access to my Healthy Junk Food Cheat Sheet + never miss a post!


Don't worry - I hate spam just as much as you do - your email is safe with me!

Privacy Policy

You have Successfully Subscribed!